The 8 Best Resorts in Montauk NY in 2025 | Right on the Sand
We researched all the options and found the best resorts in Montauk NY that offer the most relaxing, scenic, and unforgettable experiences along the easternmost tip of Long Island.
We also made sure to find options for every price point so that you can find the perfect beach resort in Montauk for your budget.
Table of Contents
Methodology
To identify the best resorts Montauk has to offer, we carefully reviewed hundreds of traveler experiences, star ratings, and photo galleries across Google Reviews, TripAdvisor, and Expedia.
We made sure to focus on amenities, beachfront access, dining quality, accommodations, and overall guest satisfaction, then used our custom formula to rate the best of the best.
Please note that some links below are affiliate links, which means that we receive a small commission if you make a purchase through our links, but at no extra cost to you. Thank you in advance for your support!
The 8 Best Montauk NY Resorts for 2025
8. Montauk Yacht Club
Key Highlights:
- Private marina with 232 boat slips
- Three pools including a heated indoor option
- Over 35 waterfront acres with direct access to Lake Montauk
This resort is for folks who want a slightly nautical but upscale kind of vibe—it’s almost like a luxe version of a boater’s paradise. As a matter of fact, the Montauk Yacht Club has been welcoming visitors since the 1920s and still pulls in that coastal-club energy without feeling stuffy.
The rooms are spacious, crisp, and kind of tailored for both families and romantic getaways, with suites that feature balconies peeking over the marina or lake. There’s a certain breezy elegance to it all—especially with the on-site restaurants that usually highlight seafood pulled straight from the nearby docks.
Three pools give you options, including a covered one for those unpredictable Montauk days. Guests can also enjoy tennis courts, lawn games, and spa treatments tucked just off the main stretch.
Located just a short drive from downtown Montauk, it’s close enough to local eateries and surf shops while still offering some peace and quiet. When it comes to Montauk NY resorts, this one’s got a strong anchor on both style and space.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
7. Marram – Most Affordable
Key Highlights:
- Direct beachfront access on the Atlantic
- 96 rooms with minimalist design
- On-site restaurant with Latin-inspired dishes
Marram is one of those properties that almost feels like it belongs on a Pinterest board—in a good way. It’s got a minimalist aesthetic that’s just a little bit elevated, with neutral tones and lots of natural textures, and yet the price tag is surprisingly reasonable for a beachfront stay.
Directly on the sand, this is one of the Montauk resorts where you can quite literally roll out of bed and be steps from the ocean. That sort of seamless beach access makes it great for both quick weekenders and longer, laid-back stays.
The on-site food is typically fresh and full of color, with Latin-inspired flavors and breezy outdoor dining spaces. Rooms keep things simple—but in a way that still feels boutique and intentionally curated.
For folks looking for the best resorts in Montauk NY without dropping a fortune, Marram is that rare mix of quality and value right on the shore.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
6. Ocean Surf Resort
Key Highlights:
- Direct beach access with complimentary lounge chairs
- Outdoor heated pool overlooking the ocean
- Kitchenettes available in most rooms
Ocean Surf Resort is a Montauk NY resort that keeps things casual but still manages to cover all the essentials pretty thoroughly. It’s not flashy, but it’s kind of perfect if you want oceanfront comfort without too much fuss.
The big draw here is really the location—it’s situated right on the beach, and there’s a private gate leading guests directly to the sand. Rooms come with kitchenettes, which is great if you’re the type to make coffee barefoot while watching waves roll in.
The pool is nice added bonus, and it’s heated and overlooks the Atlantic, which adds a little something special to even the laziest afternoons. Families seem to really appreciate the cleanliness, quiet, and self-contained nature of the resort.
With Montauk’s village area just a few blocks away, it’s easy to hit up restaurants, rental shops, and even a few surf schools without needing to drive. In terms of Montauk resorts, Ocean Surf keeps it grounded and easygoing while still giving you that sought-after beach proximity.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
5. Montauk Manor
Key Highlights:
- 22-acre estate with panoramic ocean views
- Indoor and outdoor pools plus tennis courts
- Historic 1927 architecture with unique suites
Montauk Manor brings in an old-world charm that you don’t typically expect at the beach. The place feels a bit like a castle on a hill—seriously, the grounds sit high above the coastline and give you some of the best views in town.
It’s a larger property with plenty of breathing room, spread across 22 acres, and the building itself is nearly a century old with beautifully preserved touches. Guests have access to two pools—one inside and one out—and a few tennis courts that stay busy in the warmer months.
Rooms here are condo-style, so you’re getting kitchenettes and more living space, which is really great for groups or families who want some elbow room. The style is a bit more classic than coastal, and in a way, that gives it an edge over other Montauk NY resorts.
While it’s not directly on the beach, the resort provides shuttle service, and it’s less than a 5-minute drive from Kirk Park Beach. For anyone looking for a little bit of history mixed with their salt air, Montauk Manor hits that niche just right.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
4. Hartman’s Briney Breezes Beach Resort
Key Highlights:
- Directly across from the ocean with views in nearly every room
- Outdoor pool and BBQ area
- Compact resort with only 45 units
Hartman’s Briney Breezes feels kind of like that familiar, cozy summer place people return to every year. It’s more or less got this relaxed, throwback motel style—but spruced up and better maintained than most in the category.
Located right across from the ocean, you’re never far from a beach chair or sunrise view. Most rooms face the water, which is definitely a perk that adds to the value.
There’s an outdoor pool, a little picnic setup, and some grills out back—so it’s a good match for families who want to cook a few meals on-site. What really stands out, though, is how clean and well-kept everything tends to be, according to frequent guests.
This is one of those Montauk resorts that doesn’t try too hard, but delivers where it counts. It’s a quieter scene overall, which works well for couples, seniors, or parents who need to unwind while the kids splash around.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
3. Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa – Best-Seller
Key Highlights:
- 30,000-square-foot spa and wellness center
- Only resort in Montauk with a private beach
- Five restaurants and bars on site
Gurney’s is pretty much the name people throw around first when talking about Montauk NY resorts—and for good reason. It’s the only spot in town with its own private stretch of beach, and the scale of the property gives it this all-inclusive sort of feel.
The resort spans a sizable chunk of prime oceanfront, and the views are basically everywhere—from restaurants to room balconies to spa lounges. That spa, by the way, is enormous and totally full-service, with a saltwater pool that’s heated and indoors.
Accommodations range from standard rooms to oceanfront suites and even beachfront cottages, all decked out in light, coastal-inspired decor. Dining is a big draw too—there are multiple on-site restaurants serving everything from sushi to steak, often with live music or DJs on weekends.
This one’s great for couples, groups, or solo travelers looking for a wellness-centered, food-forward experience. As far as best resorts in Montauk NY go, Gurney’s tends to stay at the top of most lists for a reason.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
2. Ocean Resort Inn – Top Value Pick
Key Highlights:
- Less than 200 feet from the beach
- 24 rooms with private patios and beach access
- Affordable pricing with strong guest reviews
Ocean Resort Inn is that solid hidden gem that somehow manages to deliver more than it costs. It’s not massive—in fact, it only has two dozen rooms—but that smaller size actually plays into the charm and laid-back nature of the place.
It’s located about half a block from the beach, so getting your toes in the sand is a pretty quick operation. Rooms are simple, clean, and each one opens to a little patio area that gives off a surprisingly serene feel.
This spot is especially popular with return guests who value location, price, and the kind of warm service that you don’t always find at bigger Montauk NY resorts. It’s also walking distance to shops and casual restaurants in the main village.
If you’re trying to enjoy the best resorts in Montauk NY without going over budget, Ocean Resort Inn stands out as a well-rounded option that punches above its weight class.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
1. Hero Beach Club – Top Overall
Key Highlights:
- Oceanfront property with curated garden courtyard
- Seasonal outdoor pool and sun deck
- 27 rooms styled with a mix of vintage and modern beach decor
We think Hero Beach Club is the best resort in Montauk NY today.
It does the best job of delivering a pleasing aesthetic, top-tier service, and excellent comfort. There’s a distinctive design focus here, from the custom furniture in rooms to the art displayed in common spaces.
It’s located right along the beach, with some rooms offering panoramic ocean views and others overlooking the beautifully landscaped inner courtyard. The vibe is laid-back but polished, and the staff typically goes out of their way to keep things running smoothly.
There’s a seasonal pool surrounded by loungers and a sun deck, plus direct beach access just across the lawn. The resort also hosts occasional wellness events and pop-ups, adding some extra energy without going overboard.
Being close to town makes it easy to explore Montauk’s shops and dining options, but honestly, you might be just fine staying put. Among the best resorts in Montauk NY, Hero Beach Club has a little bit of everything—from style and scenery to comfort and thoughtful service.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
Articles You Might Also Like
