The 10 Best Rated Hotels in New York City – 2026 Update
We analyzed every property in NYC and found the absolutely best rated hotels in New York City for visitors who truly want the best of the best.
In a city that practically reinvents itself block by block, New York remains, frankly, one of the most layered, vivid, and undeniably electric places you could decide to stay.
Whether you’re coming for the skyline, the street food, the Broadway shows, or that oddly comforting chaos of yellow taxis, you’ll need a spot that’s more than just a mattress and a minibar.
Table of Contents
Methodology
So, to put this guide together, we didn’t just skim the surface or rely on some tourist-brochure fluff.
We actually combed through thousands of reviews on Google Reviews, TripAdvisor, and Expedia, and, as a matter of fact, we weighed each comment using our internal editorial process to eliminate noise.
We used a proprietary system that considers satisfaction trends, consistency, location advantage, quality of services, guest sentiment, and long-term value.
That way, we landed on the most accurate list of the top rated hotels in New York City, each one offering something noticeably different, yet more or less ranking among the best rated hotels in NYC today.
Please note that some links below are affiliate links, which means that we receive a small commission if you make a purchase through our links, but at no extra cost to you. Thank you in advance for your support!
The Top 10 Best Rated Hotels in New York City – 2026 Update
10. 1 Hotel Central Park
Location: Midtown Manhattan, NY
Key Highlights:
- Steps away from Central Park and Fifth Avenue shopping
- 114 rooms with reclaimed wood and greenery-inspired decor
- On-site farm-to-table restaurant Jams by Chef Jonathan Waxman
Honestly, it’s almost impossible to talk about the best rated hotels in New York without putting 1 Hotel Central Park somewhere in the conversation.
This eco-conscious retreat is just a little unexpected, as it brings the outdoors inside with lots of greenery, wood textures, and daylight flooding the common areas.
The rooms are built with earthy tones and organic materials, and yet they still come with high-end touches like rain showers, filtered water taps, and soft cotton robes.
The signature restaurant Jams offers a seriously impressive seasonal menu with locally sourced ingredients, which actually draws in locals on the weekends too.
You’re literally a block from the park, a quick walk from MoMA, and the shopping options along Fifth Avenue are ridiculously close. While it doesn’t have a pool, there’s a fitness center and spa access through partnerships.
It’s not overly flashy, but it quietly delivers what many of the top rated hotels in NYC never quite get right, which is balance.
9. Best Western Plus Soho Hotel – Most Affordable
Location: Soho, Manhattan, NY
Key Highlights:
- Under 10-minute walk to Canal Street and Little Italy
- One of the best bangs-for-your-buck in Manhattan
- Free breakfast and compact but comfortable rooms
Not everyone rolls into the city with a limitless budget, and the Best Western Plus Soho Hotel proves you can still stay in one of the best rated hotels in NYC without needing to stretch your wallet beyond comfort.
It’s fairly no-frills in appearance, sure, but it’s very clean, extremely dependable, and surprisingly modern inside.
Rooms aren’t massive, but the beds are solid, there’s good Wi-Fi, and yes, you even get a free hot breakfast.
Walkability is a major perk here. In fact, you can wander right into Soho for some boutique browsing, or head a few blocks to Chinatown for seriously good dumplings.
It’s incredibly well-located, especially for travelers who want to explore lower Manhattan without burning out from constant subway rides.
As one of the top rated hotels in New York for value-focused travelers, this one’s almost shockingly consistent.
8. Crowne Plaza HY36 Midtown Manhattan, an IHG hotel
Location: Midtown West, Manhattan, NY
Key Highlights:
- Located just 2 blocks from Penn Station
- Fitness studio, lounge bar, and steakhouse on-site
- 251 modern rooms with rainfall showers
Crowne Plaza HY36 is one of those properties that surprises people. On paper, it sounds like a chain hotel with standard perks, but inside it’s a little more stylish and noticeably more thoughtful than expected.
Rooms are sleek and modern with blackout shades, super comfy beds, and noise-canceling windows, which, frankly, matter a lot this close to Penn Station.
There’s a warm and cozy cocktail lounge on-site and a steakhouse that actually serves a better-than-average ribeye.
It’s ideal for train travelers or anyone coming in from Newark or JFK because of the transit accessibility.
And unlike other midtown hotels that just throw in some “urban chic” wallpaper and call it a day, Crowne Plaza HY36 consistently lands among the top rated hotels in NYC for delivering real comfort.
7. Aloft Long Island City – Manhattan View
Location: Long Island City, Queens, NY
Key Highlights:
- Skyline views of Manhattan from many rooms
- Rooftop bar and outdoor terrace lounge
- Quick subway access into Midtown (just 1 stop)
Aloft Long Island City gives you quick access to the core of the city without making you pay Manhattan prices, and the skyline views from here are seriously good.
The vibe inside is colorful and casual, with younger travelers and creative types gravitating to the rooftop terrace or lobby lounge.
Rooms are straightforward but bright, with floor-to-ceiling windows in many, offering that postcard view of the Empire State Building.
Families often appreciate the affordability and ease of subway access, while solo travelers enjoy the communal areas for socializing.
Overall, this property manages to earn its spot among the best rated hotels in New York City thanks to the balance of value, location, and views.
6. Motto by Hilton New York City Chelsea
Location: Chelsea, Manhattan, NY
Key Highlights:
- 26 stories with skyline views in most rooms
- Modern micro-rooms with smart space-saving design
- On-site restaurant and social coworking space
In the same way that New York reinvents buildings, Motto by Hilton flips the concept of a typical hotel room. They offer some of the most well-designed rooms engineered with clever layouts that make the most of every inch.
There’s a calming modern design throughout, and the vibe is geared toward digitally savvy travelers or business guests who prefer function over fuss.
The views from the upper floors are genuinely impressive, especially at sunset.
The restaurant downstairs turns out solid craft cocktails and shareable plates, while the communal coworking space tends to fill up with laptop users by midmorning.
It might be smaller than some of the top rated hotels in New York City, but it holds its own in terms of quality, service, and location.
5. Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection – Best-Seller
Location: Times Square, Manhattan, NY
Key Highlights:
- Free continental breakfast and daily wine receptions
- Steps from Times Square, but incredibly peaceful inside
- 48 rooms with vintage-inspired decor
The Casablanca Hotel is frequently listed among the top rated hotels in New York City by guests who want charm, walkability, and little touches of luxury without the noise and chaos.
Despite being just off Times Square, it’s surprisingly calm inside, with Moroccan-inspired interiors and soft lighting that creates a restful atmosphere.
There’s a complimentary breakfast and wine-and-cheese hour daily, which, let’s be real, adds real value for tourists.
Rooms include plush bedding, thoughtful desk setups, and little perks like sound machines and robes. Families, couples, and even older travelers love it for its accessibility and warmth.
It’s arguably one of the best rated hotels in New York for those who want Midtown access without that sterile chain-hotel feeling.
4. LUMA Hotel Times Square
Location: Times Square, Manhattan, NY
Key Highlights:
- 130 rooms with floor-to-ceiling windows
- On-site Spanish tapas restaurant, Ortzi
- Smart tech including Alexa in-room assistants
LUMA Hotel Times Square sort of hits that sweet spot between modern and relaxed.
You’re close enough to the action, just off Bryant Park and Times Square, but the hotel still feels sleek and business-class without being too stiff.
Rooms are all glass, steel, and neutral tones, and they’re loaded with smart tech, like Alexa voice service, remote curtains, and fast Wi-Fi.
Ortzi, the hotel’s Spanish-style restaurant, serves up some seriously rich tapas and wine pairings, and it’s well-reviewed by locals too.
Guests frequently mention how quiet the rooms are, despite being in one of NYC’s noisiest zones. It continues to land on best rated hotels in New York City lists because it rarely misses a beat on service, cleanliness, or location.
3. Pendry Manhattan West
Location: Midtown West, Manhattan, NY
Key Highlights:
- 164 rooms and suites with California-inspired interiors
- Signature restaurant Zou Zou’s plus chic cocktail bar
- Walking distance to The High Line and The Shed
The Pendry Manhattan West is definitely where cool minimalism and modern elegance come together, in a way that feels both tailored and casually upscale.
It’s located in the newly developed Hudson Yards area, which is, more or less, one of the fastest-evolving corners of the city.
The rooms feel more West Coast than East, thanks to light wood tones, natural textures, and big windows that soften the city vibe. You’ll find 300-thread-count sheets, blackout drapes, and heated floors in the bathrooms, which are the kind of details that quietly elevate your stay.
It’s one of the best rated hotels in New York because it gives off this rare sense of calm, especially considering it’s just a few blocks from Penn Station.
For food and drink, Zou Zou’s delivers bold Mediterranean flavors, and the lobby bar serves up meticulously made cocktails that don’t try too hard.
If you’re heading to a show at The Shed or just want a breezy walk on the High Line, the location makes perfect sense. And the service? Crisp, prompt, and warm, without being overbearing.
2. The Penny Williamsburg – Top Value Pick
Location: Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Key Highlights:
- Built in 2022 with 118 pet-friendly rooms
- Art-forward design with locally curated pieces
- Less than 15 minutes to Manhattan via subway
Frankly, The Penny Williamsburg might be the least expected hotel on this list, but don’t let that fool you.
It’s one of the top rated hotels in NYC for a reason, mostly because it manages to feel original, personal, and incredibly dialed-in for modern travelers who don’t need gold-plated lobbies.
Rooms here are bright, homey, and outfitted with full kitchens or kitchenettes, which makes longer stays so much easier. There’s an art school connection, with rotating exhibits and locally inspired pieces throughout the building, giving it a strong creative energy.
Dog owners, by the way, absolutely love it. The staff treats pets like VIPs, and there’s a real sense that this hotel is designed for people who live a little differently. It’s not in Manhattan, sure, but you’re practically one subway stop from the East Village.
Among the best rated hotels in New York, this one’s incredibly well-priced without feeling watered-down. Add in the cafe-style breakfast, high ceilings, and friendly vibe, and you’ve got something that feels like it actually belongs to Brooklyn, not just built on top of it.
1. The Bryant Park Hotel – Top Overall
Location: Midtown Manhattan, NY
Key Highlights:
- 128 rooms facing Bryant Park or Fifth Avenue
- Complimentary espresso bar and 24/7 fitness center
- Located in the historic American Radiator Building
The Bryant Park Hotel is that kind of classic, quiet standout that keeps showing up on every list of the best rated hotels in New York City, and for very good reason.
It doesn’t shout its credentials, yet it consistently lands at the top thanks to strong design, intuitive service, and one of the best locations in the entire city.
Set inside a neo-Gothic landmark, the interiors mix Art Deco details with contemporary finishes. Rooms facing Bryant Park feel airy and scenic, especially in the morning when sunlight hits the trees, while Fifth Avenue rooms add a slightly busier vibe.
The bathrooms here are honestly kind of legendary, with marble finishes, deep soaking tubs, and space to actually move around.
The hotel offers access to dozens of some of Manhattan’s best eateries within a one-block radius, and the in-house espresso bar keeps guests fueled up all day long.
For travelers who care about precision, with clean lines, calm staff, fast elevators, and actual soundproofing, this is basically where the smart money stays.
Among the top rated hotels in New York City, Bryant Park Hotel strikes the rare balance of being stylish without being trendy, central without being chaotic, and always dependable without being sterile.
Articles You Might Also Like
