The 8 Best Resorts in Martha’s Vineyard | Hand-Picked for 2025
We analyzed all the beachfront properties around the island and found the best resorts in Martha’s Vineyard for travelers seeking a relaxing coastal vacation experience with stylish comfort, warm hospitality, and beautiful New England charm.
Located just a short ferry ride off the coast of Massachusetts, Martha’s Vineyard is a classic East Coast getaway spot where you can truly relax.
From Edgartown to Oak Bluffs to the quieter stretches of West Tisbury, the island offers a handful of resorts that, in fact, bring a surprising mix of luxury and coastal nostalgia.
Some of these Martha’s Vineyard resorts on the beach deliver prime water views and direct sand access, while others are tucked back for a more tranquil vibe.
Table of Contents
Methodology
To create this ranking of the best resorts Martha’s Vineyard has to offer, we researched dozens of properties on Booking.com, Google Reviews, TripAdvisor, and Expedia.
We analyzed real guest feedback, staff responsiveness, photos, and updated amenities to assess what each resort currently offers.
Then, our editors applied a proprietary scoring model based on location, beach access, family features, price-to-value ratio, and overall experience to finalize the rankings.
Each of the resorts on Martha’s Vineyard we included below consistently ranks highly among travelers and locals alike.
The 8 Best Martha’s Vineyard Resorts – 2025 Full Guide
8. Faraway Martha’s Vineyard
Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Key Highlights:
- 5-minute walk to Edgartown Harbor
- Completely renovated in 2022 with eclectic, high-end design
- 49 guest rooms across multiple historic buildings
Faraway Martha’s Vineyard offers a vibe that is stylish and chic, with custom textiles, brass fixtures, and vintage maritime decor.
It’s almost like this boutique resort in Edgartown pulled together the old-school character of the island and gave it a new, modern spin.
Rooms here are thoughtfully designed, with a bit of a mix between polished beach casual and downtown loft, and they span from cozy queens to airy multi-room suites.
Guests are more or less minutes away from South Beach and Norton Point Beach by bike or car, which is kind of perfect for those who plan to spend most of their time outdoors anyway.
Faraway Martha’s Vineyard might not be loaded with family programming, but it tends to be great for couples or solo travelers who appreciate attention to visual detail and walkable convenience.
With an on-site restaurant and coffee bar serving up things like espresso and breakfast sandwiches, it’s also got that rare combination of low-key and refined.
It’s central, so, you’re near everything Edgartown has to offer, from art galleries to harbor strolls to boutique shops.
7. Lambert’s Cove Inn & Resort – Most Affordable
Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Key Highlights:
- 7-acre wooded property with access to private Lambert’s Cove Beach
- 15 rooms in multiple buildings
- Highly-rated farm-to-table dining onsite
- One of the most budget-friendly resorts Martha’s Vineyard offers
Lambert’s Cove Inn & Resort, located in West Tisbury, offers a very peaceful, nature-surrounded escape that’s honestly kind of ideal for travelers who’d rather avoid the crowds.
Set back in the woods and spread across a large, shaded property, this resort focuses a little more on relaxation and a lot less on fuss.
The 15 rooms are fairly spread out, giving off a bit of retreat-style privacy, and they range from charming main house quarters to newer guest cottages.
Guests have exclusive access to Lambert’s Cove Beach, a nearly hidden-away gem that’s one of the most photogenic and quietest beaches on the island.
The onsite restaurant is surprisingly upscale for such a cozy property, and it’s pretty common to hear people rave about the housemade pasta and seasonal seafood dishes.
It’s not flashy or showy, but if you’re looking for resorts in Martha’s Vineyard that keep the prices somewhat more manageable while still offering beautiful scenery and quality service, this is your pick.
Families might find it a bit subdued, but couples and quiet travelers will feel right at home.
6. The Harborside Inn
Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Key Highlights:
- Edgartown Harbor location with a private dock
- Multiple room types across 7 historic houses
- Outdoor waterfront pool with harbor views
The Harborside Inn, which is situated in the middle of Edgartown, practically places you right on the edge of the harbor.
This is one of the largest resorts in Martha’s Vineyard, yet it somehow still manages to feel intimate.
The resort is made up of seven separate buildings, many of which are classic New England-style mansions, and each holds rooms ranging from king studios to suites with private balconies.
There’s a surprisingly large outdoor pool right on the water, which is pretty rare on the island, and the resort’s private marina dock adds a nice touch for boaters or sunset watchers.
Here, you’re just a short bike ride or shuttle from Lighthouse Beach and South Beach.
For dining, there’s no on-site restaurant, but Edgartown’s top dining spots are literally right outside the door, so you’re not exactly missing out.
The Harborside is fairly family-friendly, though its layout and harborfront setting also make it a smart pick for older couples or groups looking for a social-but-comfortable atmosphere.
It’s one of the Martha’s Vineyard resorts that stays busy, so it’s best to book early.
5. Summercamp
Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Key Highlights:
- Fully renovated historic building from 1879
- Located directly across from Oak Bluffs Harbor
- 95 rooms, many with harbor views
Summercamp is a little bit retro, kind of whimsical, and actually, just really fun in a way that makes it stand out.
Located right in Oak Bluffs, this large resort has a playful summer-camp theme that feels nostalgic without being gimmicky.
With 95 rooms, many of which feature bright colors, reclaimed wood, and custom art, it’s a property that doesn’t take itself too seriously while still delivering great service.
Rooms vary in size, from compact twins to king waterfront suites, and the lobby and game rooms are equipped with snacks and old-school games for kids (or nostalgic adults).
There’s no pool here, but you are within walking distance to Inkwell Beach and the Oak Bluffs ferry terminal, so the water is never far.
For dining, there’s a casual cafe and snack bar, though most people head out to the many nearby restaurants.
Summercamp tends to be very family-friendly, and the vibe is energetic but not overwhelming.
It’s one of those resorts on Martha’s Vineyard where you’ll often find multigenerational families booking year after year.
4. The Christopher
Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Key Highlights:
- 15-room boutique resort in the center of Edgartown
- Modern Caribbean decor with bold color schemes
- Private courtyard with fire pits and lounge space
The Christopher, a modern boutique resort tucked just off Main Street in Edgartown, mixes beachy charm with bold design in a way that, frankly, makes it kind of unforgettable.
This is definitely not your grandmother’s Martha’s Vineyard inn. It’s brightly decorated with Caribbean-inspired interiors and stylish finishes in each of its 15 guest rooms, making it one of the most unique resorts Martha’s Vineyard has to offer.
The vibe is relaxed but polished, perfect for adults who appreciate a quiet stay without sacrificing style.
The courtyard offers a great little social space with fire pits, loungers, and self-serve wine fridges for evening hangs. While it’s not directly on the water, beaches like Lighthouse Beach and South Beach are easy to get to by bike or shuttle.
Breakfast is included and usually features fresh pastries and local ingredients, and guests are a short walk to some of the island’s best seafood spots.
This isn’t the most kid-centric resort, so families might want more space and programming elsewhere, but for couples or friends traveling together, it’s one of the best resorts in Martha’s Vineyard for boutique luxury.
3. Winnetu Oceanside Resort – Best-Seller
Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Key Highlights:
- Steps from South Beach with private path access
- Outdoor heated pool, hot tub, and fitness center
- Dining at The Dunes restaurant with ocean views
Winnetu Oceanside Resort, sitting right at the edge of South Beach in Edgartown, is very much a family-favorite and easily one of the most feature-rich Martha’s Vineyard resorts on the beach.
It’s the kind of spot where you can show up and not really have to leave the property unless you want to, because, well, they’ve kind of thought of everything.
Rooms range from simple studios to multi-bedroom townhomes and larger vacation rentals, so larger families or groups have plenty of flexibility.
One of the top draws here is the private beach path, which gets you from your room to the sand in just a few minutes.
The beach itself is long, wide, and clean, ideal for swimming, relaxing, or chasing waves with little ones.
Onsite, there’s a seasonal heated pool, a fully equipped fitness center, and tennis courts, plus lots of activities like yoga classes and supervised kids’ programs.
The Dunes restaurant provides both indoor and terrace dining with a menu full of fresh seafood and casual classics, which makes meals easy and surprisingly upscale.
Winnetu is an excellent resort Martha’s Vineyard visitors often return to, partly because of its location and partly because it manages to stay welcoming to both adults and families.
2. Mansion House – Top Value Pick
Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Key Highlights:
- Fitness center with 75-foot indoor lap pool and spa
- Views of Vineyard Haven Harbor from rooftop deck
- Close proximity to ferry terminal and Main Street
Mansion House in Vineyard Haven is, arguably, the top value pick among resorts in Martha’s Vineyard if you’re looking for amenities, walkability, and modern comforts without paying top-tier prices.
This full-service resort delivers more than it promises, with a surprisingly extensive spa and wellness area, including a lap pool, steam rooms, and personal training services.
Rooms are clean, comfortable, and decorated in a classic coastal style, with many offering harbor views or fireplaces for a cozy touch.
For those who like staying central, the location right on Main Street makes it easy to explore shops, cafes, and local galleries by foot.
Owen Park Beach and Lagoon Pond are within just a few minutes’ walk, which makes it one of the best resorts in Martha’s Vineyard for value-seekers who also want to be close to the water.
It’s also a convenient base for first-time visitors since the ferry dock is only a short walk away.
Breakfast is offered next door at the independently owned restaurant, and the overall experience is one of warm service with modern updates.
If you’re trying to experience Martha’s Vineyard resorts without spending a fortune, this one delivers a very solid balance of access, comfort, and price.
1. Harbor View Hotel – Top Overall
Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Key Highlights:
- Prime location overlooking Edgartown Lighthouse and Harbor
- 51 upscale rooms and suites plus luxury residences
- Outdoor heated pool and on-site restaurant, Bettini
Harbor View Hotel, located right across from Edgartown Lighthouse, is, without question, the best resort in Martha’s Vineyard.
This iconic retreat feels timeless but not old-fashioned. With a blend of coastal luxury and colonial-style charm, the property has recently undergone a series of renovations that elevated everything from the rooms to the landscaping.
Accommodations span from cozy queen rooms in the historic main inn to fully decked-out multi-bedroom residences with kitchens, which work really well for longer stays.
The outdoor heated pool area offers a bit of a resort feel in a town where that can be rare, and the on-site spa provides massage services by appointment.
What makes this place stand out, though, is the location: you can walk directly to Lighthouse Beach in just a couple minutes, and the harbor is literally in your view the moment you step out front, making it one of the best Martha’s Vineyard resorts on the beach as well.
Bettini, the upscale on-site restaurant, is frequently mentioned by locals and travelers alike for its seasonal menu, harborfront dining, and elevated service.
Families are welcome here, and they often appreciate the location, spacious suites, and activities nearby, but the property feels equally suited for couples or wedding guests.
Of all the resorts on Martha’s Vineyard, this one feels the most complete, like a proper destination in itself, rather than just a place to stay.
Articles You Might Also Like
